OK. It’s three AM and I am in a drug induced daze, so feel free to take this thing and axe it if you yearn to do so.
First, a “chimu” is a “team” in Japan. You can guess what a “charrenge” is. The goal is to make the top team of position players using only alliterative names.
Rules: Using Fangraphs for WAR, create a collection of all alliterative top talent for each and every position:
C
1B
2B
SS
3B
LF
CF
RF
Five man rotation (if possible)
Three relievers.
DH
List the player name and their best single-season WAR at that position. Since this blog is basically built with left-leaning, liberal people, feel free to be bery liberal with any examples. Nicknames? OK. Successive glottal stops? Great. Go. I’ll be back in a while, when I’ve actually gotten good sleep.
Wasn’t somebody around here a throat singer for the Successive Glottal Stops?
So, Mickey Mantle? Bay Brooth? Ank Aaron? Barry ‘n Bobby? And our own Coco Crisp, David Dejesus, Kevin Kousmanoff and Billy Beane?
Scooby language? Ralbert Rujols?
Active Players:
C: Miguel Montero
1B: Billy Butler
2B: Placido Polanco
SS: Tulo
3B: Melvin Mora
LF: Acronym
CF: DDJ
RF: Shin Soo (Choo)
Five man rotation (if possible): C C (sabathia); Carpenter; Doug Davis; Josh Johnson; Ricky Romero
Three relievers: Scot Shields; J J (putz); Darren (O’) Day
DH: Kila Ka’aihue
Let me clarify: I’m talking all time team, with single season performances.
Also, this seemed like a much better idea under the influence.
I would start with:
1B: Mark McGwire ’98 (8.8 WAR)
LF: Barry Bonds ’02 (13.0)
CF: MIckey Mantle ’56 (12.2)
SP: Mark Mulder ’01 (5.8)
SP: Chris Carpenter ’05 (6.8)
RF: Sammy Sosa ’01 (10.4)
2B: “Moneyball” Morgan ’75 (11.4)
With nicknames, the Bambino’s gotta be in there.
I completely misunderstood this and was going for a team of players whose names all started with the same letter.
I hadn’t got as far as the relievers, but thanks to their pitching the S’s seems to have a decent shout:
C: Simmons 6.3
1B: Sisler 11.2
2B: Stirnweiss 9.2
SS: Stephens 8.2
3B: Santo 10.2
RF: Sosa 10.4
CF: Speaker 11.0
LF: Stone 9.7
DH: Seitzer 4.2
SP: Schilling 9.7
SP: Smoltz 8.4
SP: Saberhagen 8.4
SP: Soto 8.0
SP: Sheets 8.0
That’s sufficiently solid squad.
RP: Saito 3.2
RP: Stanley 3.1
RP: Smith 3.0
So with 132.2 WAR that team should be good for 155 or so wins in a 162-game season, right?
All-time alliterative team of former players buried in unmarked graves: sufficiently squalid sod.
I might take the Splendid Splinter over Bonds in left field. His top single-season WAR (B-Ref) was 11.8 in 1946 and career WAR was 125.3 (Bonds 12.5 in 2001 and 171.8); consider, though, that Williams completely missed his ages 24-26 seasons in 1943-1945 and then totaled just 122 plate appearances in 1952-1953. His career OPS+ was 190 vs. 181 for Bonds. Bonds was a much better defensive player until his body type changed, but Williams played half his games in Fenway’s left field so the defense wasn’t as critical.
And Splendid Splinter is definitely the alliterative man to beat.
No, Masturbatin’ Matsui is the man to beat.
asvd
Coca Cola–>nose–>keyboard.
In the heyday of corny sportswriting many of the big stars had nicknames that would qualify under JL’s rules; the Sultan of Swat as you reference above, Hammerin’ Hank, Rapid Robert…
Today we live in the heymanday of corny sportswriting
I guess the numbers just don’t add up for Jersey Jack.
… nor, apparently, will they for Masturbatin’ Matsui.
But Pretty Pretty Mike Piazza might get the nod.
Combining ptbnl’s idea with JL’s (top single-season WAR in parentheses):
C: Bob Boone (3.5)
1B: Bill Buckner (3.7)
2B: Bret Boone (8.2)
SS: Brian Bocock (-0.1)
3B: Bobby Bonilla (5.7) or Buddy Bell (6.9!)
LF: Barry Bonds (12.5) (Sorry Bruce Bochte)
CF: Brett Butler (5.1)
RF: Bobby Bonds (6.7)
DH: Billy Butler (4.5)
SP: Brad Bergesen (2.8), Brandon Backe (0.5), Boof Bonser (1.3), Brian Bannister (3.3), Bo Belinsky (2.2)
RP: Brian Boehringer (1.6),Blaine Boyer (0.6),…
Manager: Bruce Bochy
Pitching Coach: Bud Black
General Manager: Billy Beane
Bravo!
C: Mike Macfarlane (3.7)
1B: Mark McGwire (8.8)
2B: Mark McLemore (4.3)
SS: Mickey Morandini (4.3)
3B: Melvin Mora (6.4)
LF: Minnie Miñoso (8.3)
CF: Mickey Mantle (12.2)
RF: Manny Mota (3.4)
DH: Matt Murton (3.1)
SP: Mike Mussina (7.1)
SP: Matt Morris (6.0)
SP: Mike Moore (6.0)
SP: Mark Mulder (5.8)
SP: Mike Morgan (4.5)
RP: Mike Marshall (3.9)
RP: Mike Maddux (2.4)
RP: Matt Mantei (1.5)
Mazel Tov!
I love that Minnie and Mickey (X2) are both on the team.
I’m too lazy to get the WARs, but here’s my all-time Oakland A’s alliterative 25-man roster:
Starting Lineup:
Mike MacFarlane C
Mark McGwire 1B
Scott Spiezio 2B
Kevin Kouzmanoff 3B
Walt Weiss SS
Willie Wilson RF
David DeJesus LF
Coco Crisp CF
John Jaha DH
Bench:
Chris Carter OF/1B
Gabe Gross OF
Bruce Bochte 1B
Mark McLemore IF
Dave Duncan C
Starting Pitchers:
Mark Mulder SP
Mike Moore SP
Scott Sanderson SP
Omar Olivares SP
Chris Codiroli SP
Bullpen:
Ricardo Rincon, RP
Mike Magnante, RP
Mike Mohler, RP
Kiko Calero, RP
Goose Gossage, RP
Jeff Jones, RP
Staff:
Billy Beane, GM
Jack McKeon, Manager (ok, that’s a stretch, but unless you go to Mel McGaha in Kansas City, it’s the best we got)
Duffy Dyer, Base Coach
Billy Williams, Hitting Coach (another stretch)
Dave Duncan, Pitching Coach (player-coach!)
Ron Romanick, Bullpen Coach
Ken Korach, Radio Announcer
Monte Moore, TV Announcer
The Dynasty years of 72-74 were seriously lacking in alliteration.
You could probably count “Campy” Campaneris.
I thought about that, but it felt a little like cheating.
Yeah, I think for these purposes only “real” nicknames and derisive fake ones should count — once you let in Campy, you gotta let in “Huddy” Hudson.
No Jason Giambi?
oooh, nice.
Oops, yes, as a player, I guess he should go ahead of Bruce Bochte. But not as a name.
Mickey Morabito, Director of Team Travel
Mgr: Best-man Bob
Mark Ellis Never Errs. Crappy-Hitting Italian: Never Ok.
menefreghismo?