Today is draft day, which means it’s time for my annual FKing cameo. With so little baseball and so much going on in the world, other than shitty behaviour by owners, the draft is about all the baseball we have to talk about.
MLB has cut the draft to just 5 rounds and teams will be making decisions based on much less information than usual. The draft class is reportedly quite deep, especially in college pitching (including a record number of draft eligible sophmores) and shortstops. Also at play is the likelihood that there is a significant reduction in the number of minor leage teams before the 2021 season. There’s all kinds of speculation about what this all may mean. There’s even a rumour that a team may choose to punt the entire 2020 draft. But that seems both dumb and unlikely. Long story short: I expect there will be some wacky shit going on, but it’s hard to even know what kind of wacky shit.
A’s pick 26th and given all the uncertainty I wouldn’t read much into the various reports. That said I have read that they have been tied mostly to college pitchers and middle infielders, both HS and college.
Draft starts at 7pm ET, picks 1-37 happen tonight and the remaining 4 rounds tomorrow.
thanks for starting this. I have paid less attention this year than in the past.
I’m sure you aren’t alone. Without actual baseball being played there’s little to pay attention to.
A deep draft class with limited widely available information would appear to favor organizations with strong analytics and an eye for hidden value. Do we still have a mirror of Farhan’s laptop?
KLaw has the Tigers picking a college 1Bman (Spencer Torkelson, from Petaluma) at #1. That seems unusual.
The last hitter I remember being spoken of as glowingly as Torkelson coming into the draft was Bryce Harper. That worked out well. On the pitching side, Stephen Strasburg and Mark Appel. Youse takes yer chances in this thing.
Torkelson defintely has a special bat. He obviously doesn’t have the speed of Harper but his track record of hitting gives a lot of confidence in him as a prospect. Which I think also party explains why he’s likely to go first. In a year with so much uncertainty, the relative safety makes him very attractive.
KLaw is streaming here fyi.
I wonder if UCLA OF Garrett Mitchell is in play for the A’s since they drafted him 3 years ago but it looks like he’s projected to go before they pick.
Mitchell is now one of the bigger wild cards in the draft. I’ve read a couple places that there are some concerns about his swing and uncertainty around his diabetes, but it still seems unlikely that he makes it to the A’s at 26.
Yeah the diabetes thing is concerning for me after seeing how it affected Michael Taylor. It’s a very short list of successful everyday MLB players with diabetes.
Manfred is a disengenous little shit.
Tigers take Torkelson, as expected. Only surprised is Tigers listed him as a 3b.
Kerstad goes #2, which is a bit of a surprise.
Sounds like it’s going to be a bit of a chaotic draft which should be fun.
Max Meyer #3 to marlins. Most folks thought Lacy would be the first pitcher off the board.
Lacy at #4 to KC
Jays must be thrilled to get Martin at #5
Mariners take Emerson Hancock,
Nick Gonzales to the Pirates
And the first high schoolers get taken: Robert Hassell to Padres, Rockies take Zach Veen, and then Detmers to the Angels.
Foscue at #14 is interesting, but not shocking that a college MI moved up, even with the question marks.
I think there’s a lot of college arms left on the board right where the A’s are projected to pick so feels like we’re probably going that direction.
Seems likely. Although if Mitchell keeps falling, they may pounce.
Ok, we have our first real wierdness: Boston takes Nick Yorke. BA had him at 96, MLB Pipeline at 139.
Is jessica mendoza my mom?
“Can you imagine using zoom calls and the internet to draft a guy?”
I want westberg so we can make replacements jokes
You’re on notice, Sean Murphy.
Wow a prep C? This definitely isn’t the A’s of ten years ago.
Well, Billy still likes pedigree.
BA on Soderstrom:
MLB:
Baseball Prospectus:
Don’t make a Daric Barton comp.Don’t make a Daric Barton comp.Joe Mauer!
From brief video, I’d guess he weighed more at age 15 than DB did at 30.
Fangraphs:
He sounds basically position-less at this point which is pretty scary for a 1st round prep pick. OTOH the bat must be amazing if they’re willing to overlook all of these concerns, and it’s certainly not a boring selection.
The track record on prep catchers is um…not good.
Still less risky than taking a college football player.
Too soon.
Yeah, ouch. I liked the Murray pick at the time, but it was risky.
The only successful one I can think of is Bryce Harper.
Harper was JuCo. I remember him being highly touted enough that there was advance publicity when he came up here to play in Carson City, but it was 26°F or something so I passed.
A guy who coached my kid in the fall played with him in a showcase once. He said he was nice, but the hoopla around him was stunning. Also the coach implied that the amateurness of Mr Harpers participation was….questionable
Not just any JuCo league either. The Scenic West Athletic Conference, which is a wooden bat league.
If I was a rich athlete I’d probably not choose to live in Turlock, no matter how much they liked Truckin’ there.
The Motel 6 in Turlock might have been one of the last to charge only $19.99. Cheap enough that it made sense to drive after work and stay out there on a Friday night before a weekend in Yosemite, rather than hanging back in Oakland and having to do that extra 1 hr 45 min of driving on Saturday morning.
Ever see what Dustin Pedroia said about his hometown of Woodland?
I have the same reviews as scouts watching this. Catching looks pretty terrible, bat looks fantastic.
Yeah, I’m a fan of the bat. And maybe don’t care if he’s not a catcher.
This may be totally off base but he kind of reminds me of John Jaso.
KLaw’s first day wrapup at The Athletic. He projected Soderstrom to get picked between 9 and 13, but thinks that it made sense for him to drop this far due to lack of a position.
And I think teams were a little reluctant to take high schoolers early, which makes sense under the circumstances, given the less extensive track record and greater leverage HS guys have.
Still a lot of talent on the board for the A’s here, but with an overslot deal for Soderstrom the A’s aren’t likely taking one of the top guys who have slid.
A’s take Jeff Criswell, one of the top college arms still available:
BA:
Reminds me a bit of Treinen – drafted as a starter but stuff and command plays up as a reliever. Relies on heavy sink and a slider.
Uh, how the heck did the Dodgers score a Competitive Balance Round pick?
Ah, looks like it was a trade with MIN.
I just want to say that this year’s draft format is FKing awful. There’s no reason to trot out Vasgersian to announce 100 something picks and do a 4 min rundown on some unranked Juco kid that the analysts literally are just learning about that instant.
I get that it’s just 5 rounds this year and they’re milking the only baseball related content we’ve had in 3 months, but with commercial breaks, this shit started 4 hours ago and they’re only halfway through round 4.
The commercial breaks are what did it for me. The draft just isn’t interesting enough television for me to watch commercials. I use the draft tracker myself. And that’s from someone who enjoys the draft.
Yeah my usual Day 2 pastime is checking the tracker every 15-20 min or so to see the latest A’s pick but when 15 min goes by and only 4 picks have been made, it’s infuriating.
Round 3: Michael Guldberg:
BA #310
MLB UR:
Round 4: Dane Acker
BA #134
MLB UR
Round 5: Stevie Emanuels
BA #104
MLB #163
I couldn’t help notice that Acker has played for 3 different schools in as many years. That a little unusual.
would there have to be an eligibility work around?
Rice to San Jacinto JC is a pretty weird transfer, at least from an academic perspective (I realize that it was not about academics).
Isn’t that something about managing draft eligibility? Barry Zito did something similar, starting at UCSB, then a year at a JuCo, then “back up” to USC which is where he was when the A’s took him.
I do know that players can be drafted from JuCos at any time, so maybe it was an effort to get drafted early and then he transfered back to a 4 year because it’s higher profile? I’m going to have to do a little digging.
Ok, one thing I have figured out is that players who transfer between 4 year schools often have to sit out for a year, so that helps explain why he and Zito didn’t go directly from 4 year schools to other 4 year schools. Still not clear why he left Rice.
While it’s not definitive, I do see that long time Rice coach Wayne Graham was forced out after the 2018 season. Seems like the two could be related.
Law says he left Rice “probably to protect his arm,” whatever that means.
I can normally see that in College if you have a coach throwing everyone aggressively in Regionals, etc. But looking at Rice’s 2018 season I dont get it.
Maybe he got frustrated about not being able to find a girlfriend at Rice.
I’m curious how many undrafted guys we will be able to sign while our scouts are hitting the unemployment line.
He seems to be a catcher and went to what should have been my school
The A’s hove now signed three undrafted free agents, far behind some other teams.
I wonder if he is thinking of it as a $20,000 advance on his book deal?
Fifth Crimson player in the A’s system in the Forst era.
Crimson and Forst’r, over and over
ASVD!
The greatest A’s player ever to hail from Harvard is still active. He might even be in that second group they store in Stockton.
I don’t know, Jack Jones‘ 1883 season was pretty good.
From CT, goes to Harvard?